Cold brew coffee has surged in popularity over the past decade, offering coffee lovers a smooth, less acidic alternative to traditional hot brewed coffee. Unlike its hot counterpart, cold brew is made by steeping coarse coffee grounds in cold or room temperature water for an extended period, typically 12 to 24 hours. This process results in a concentrated coffee extract that is often diluted with water or milk before serving.
The cold brew method extracts different compounds from the coffee beans compared to hot brewing, resulting in a distinct flavor profile that many describe as smoother and less bitter. It’s particularly popular during warmer months but has become a year-round staple for many coffee enthusiasts.
Key Features to Consider When Buying Cold Brew Coffee
- Caffeine Content: Cold brew often has a higher caffeine concentration than regular coffee, varying significantly between brands.
- Flavor Profile: Look for descriptions of taste notes, acidity levels, and overall flavor intensity.
- Packaging: Consider convenience factors like single-serve cans versus larger bottles or concentrates.
- Organic and Fair Trade Certifications: These can be important for environmentally and socially conscious consumers.
- Shelf Life: Check the expiration date and storage requirements.
- Concentrate vs. Ready-to-Drink: Concentrates offer more versatility but require dilution.
- Additional Ingredients: Some brands add flavors, milk, or sweeteners.
- Price per Serving: Calculate this to compare value across different packaging options.
Top 10 Cold Brew Coffee Brands 2024
Stumptown Original Cold Brew
Stumptown Coffee Roasters’ Original Cold Brew stands out with its rich, smooth flavor profile featuring distinct chocolate notes. This premium offering boasts a high caffeine content of approximately 279 mg per 10.5 fl oz, packaged in a sleek glass bottle. Stumptown’s commitment to sustainably sourced, high-quality beans is evident in every sip. While the price point is higher, at around $4.29 per serving, many coffee connoisseurs find the superior taste and ethical sourcing worth the investment. The cold brew contains no additives, just coffee and water, appealing to purists. However, its premium pricing and limited availability in some regions may deter more budget-conscious consumers.
Chameleon Organic Cold Brew
Chameleon Cold-Brew offers an organic, Fair Trade certified concentrate that delivers a smooth, balanced flavor. With about 200 mg of caffeine per 10 fl oz, it provides a solid energy boost. The glass bottle packaging preserves the concentrate’s freshness and quality. Priced at approximately $3.79 per serving when diluted, Chameleon offers good value, especially considering its organic certification. The concentrate format allows users to customize their drink strength, though some may find the dilution process inconvenient. Its versatility makes it an excellent choice for those who enjoy experimenting with different coffee preparations.
Starbucks Nitro Cold Brew
Starbucks brings its familiar flavor profile to the cold brew market with its Nitro Cold Brew. Packaged in nitrogen-infused cans, this offering stands out with its uniquely creamy texture and smooth taste. Each 12 fl oz can contains a robust 280 mg of caffeine, catering to those seeking a strong energy boost. Priced at around $3.58 per can when purchased in an 8-pack, it’s a premium option that offers the convenience of ready-to-drink packaging. The nitrogen infusion creates a velvety mouthfeel without the need for additional creamers, making it an attractive option for black coffee drinkers looking for a smoother experience.
Trader Joe's Cold Brew
Trader Joe’s Cold Brew Coffee Concentrate offers an affordable entry point into the world of cold brew. Packaged in a glass bottle, this concentrate typically has a lower caffeine content compared to competitors, making it suitable for those who prefer a milder coffee experience. Priced at around $5.49 per bottle, which yields multiple servings, it represents excellent value for money. The mild, approachable flavor profile makes it versatile for various coffee drinks and appeals to a wide range of palates. However, its availability is limited to Trader Joe’s stores, which may be inconvenient for some consumers.
La Colombe Cold Brew
La Colombe’s Brazilian Cold Brew delivers a well-balanced, smooth flavor in convenient single-serve cans. With 180 mg of caffeine per 9 fl oz can, it offers a moderate energy boost. Priced at around $3.33 per can, it sits in the premium segment of the market. La Colombe’s commitment to quality is evident in their no-additives, no-preservatives approach. The ready-to-drink format is perfect for on-the-go consumption, though the limited flavor options may not appeal to those who enjoy variety. Coffee aficionados who appreciate craft beverages will likely find the quality justifies the higher price point.
Good & Gather Cold Brew
Target’s in-house brand, Good & Gather, offers a cold brew concentrate that balances quality and affordability. Priced at about $7.99 for a bottle of concentrate, it provides multiple servings, making it an economical choice. The flavor profile is generally smooth and well-rounded, catering to a wide range of coffee preferences. While it may not have the same craft coffee credentials as some premium brands, Good & Gather’s cold brew offers reliable quality and good value. Its availability in Target stores makes it easily accessible for many consumers, though this could also be a limitation for those without a nearby Target.
Death Wish Cold Brew
Living up to its name, Death Wish Cold Brew is known for its extremely high caffeine content, making it a favorite among those seeking a powerful energy boost. Priced at approximately $39.99 for a 12-pack, it’s a premium option for serious caffeine enthusiasts. The flavor is typically bold and intense, reflecting the brand’s focus on strong coffee. While the high caffeine content (around 300 mg per serving) is a major selling point for some, it may be too intense for others. The ready-to-drink cans offer convenience, but the strong flavor and high price point make it a niche product.
High Brew Coffee
High Brew Coffee offers a range of cold brew options, with their nitro black variety standing out. Priced at around $36.00 for a 12-pack, it falls in the mid-range of cold brew pricing. High Brew distinguishes itself with a variety of flavored options alongside its black coffee, catering to those who enjoy different taste profiles. The nitro-infusion in some of their products provides a smooth, creamy texture. With moderate caffeine content and a balanced flavor, High Brew positions itself as an everyday cold brew option for those seeking quality without an extreme caffeine kick.
Stōk Cold Brew
Stōk Cold Brew offers a more accessible entry point into the cold brew market. Priced at typically $28.99 for a 48 oz pack, it provides good value for those who consume cold brew regularly. Stōk’s cold brew is known for its smooth, less acidic flavor profile, making it appealing to those who find traditional coffee too harsh. The brand offers both black and flavored varieties, catering to different preferences. While it may not have the artisanal credentials of some premium brands, Stōk delivers a consistent, enjoyable cold brew experience at a more affordable price point.
Grady's Cold Brew
Grady’s Cold Brew stands out with its unique New Orleans-style flavor profile, incorporating chicory and a special spice blend. Priced at around $69 for a case of six concentrates, it’s positioned as a premium, distinctive option. The concentrate format allows for versatility in preparation, appealing to those who like to customize their coffee strength. Grady’s offers a rich, complex flavor that sets it apart from traditional cold brews. While the price point and distinctive taste may not appeal to all consumers, it has carved out a niche for those seeking a more adventurous cold brew experience.
Comparison Table
| Brand | Caffeine Content | Packaging | Price per Serving | Organic/Fair Trade | Flavor Profile |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stumptown | 279 mg/10.5 oz | Bottle | $4.29 | Yes | Rich, chocolatey |
| Chameleon | 200 mg/10 oz | Bottle (concentrate) | $3.79 | Yes | Smooth, balanced |
| Starbucks Nitro | 280 mg/12 oz | Can | $3.58 | No | Creamy, bold |
| Trader Joe's | Varies (lower) | Bottle (concentrate) | ~$1.50 | No | Mild, versatile |
| La Colombe | 180 mg/9 oz | Can | $3.33 | No | Smooth, well-balanced |
| Good & Gather | Varies | Bottle (concentrate) | ~$2.00 | No | Smooth, well-rounded |
| Death Wish | ~300 mg/8 oz | Can | $3.33 | Organic | Bold, intense |
| High Brew | ~155 mg/8 oz | Can | $3.00 | No | Balanced, various flavors |
| Stōk | ~145 mg/12 oz | Bottle | $2.41 | No | Smooth, less acidic |
| Grady's | Varies | Bottle (concentrate) | ~$2.88 | No | Unique, New Orleans-style |
Summary
After reviewing these 10 diverse cold brew coffee options, it’s clear that the market offers something for every taste preference and budget. Here’s a summary of our findings:
Best Overall Pick: Stumptown Original Cold Brew
Best Budget Option: Trader Joe's Cold Brew
Trader Joe’s remains the best budget option, offering a versatile concentrate at an unbeatable price point. It’s an excellent choice for those new to cold brew or looking to enjoy it regularly without breaking the bank.
Best Premium Option: La Colombe Cold Brew
La Colombe stands out in the premium category with its expertly crafted, well-balanced flavor. The convenient canned format and smooth taste justify the higher price for those seeking a luxury cold brew experience.
Best High-Caffeine Option: Death Wish Cold Brew
For those seeking an extra energy boost, Death Wish Cold Brew is the clear winner. Its extremely high caffeine content and bold flavor make it perfect for coffee lovers who need a powerful pick-me-up.
Most Unique Flavor: Grady's Cold Brew
Grady’s New Orleans-style cold brew offers a distinctive flavor profile that sets it apart from the competition. It’s an excellent choice for those looking to explore beyond traditional cold brew tastes.
When choosing a cold brew coffee:
- Consider your caffeine preferences: Options range from mild (Trader Joe's) to extremely high (Death Wish).
- Think about convenience: Ready-to-drink options like Starbucks Nitro and High Brew offer grab-and-go ease, while concentrates like Chameleon and Grady's allow for customization.
- Factor in price: There's a wide range, from budget-friendly Trader Joe's to premium options like Stumptown.
- Consider ethical sourcing: If this is important to you, look for organic and Fair Trade certifications offered by brands like Stumptown and Chameleon.
- Flavor profile: From the traditional (La Colombe) to the unique (Grady's), there's a wide range of flavor experiences available.
For newcomers, starting with a middle-ground option like Good & Gather or Stōk can be a good way to explore cold brew without a significant investment. Coffee enthusiasts might prefer to splurge on premium options like Stumptown or La Colombe for their superior flavor profiles.
Remember that taste is subjective, and what works best for one person may not be ideal for another. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different brands and preparations to find your perfect cold brew match. Whether you prioritize flavor, caffeine content, convenience, or value, there’s a cold brew coffee out there for you.