What Are The Best Coffee Alternatives?

Reviewed and fact-checked by certified nutritionists.

In this guide:

Many people are addicted to their morning cup of coffee. When they don’t have it, they feel tired, sluggish, unable to focus for more than 10 seconds…
The problem with coffee is that the energy boost usually doesn’t last long: after a few hours, the afternoon crash kicks in, and we’re slumped over our desks. Coffee can also cause strong “jitters” of nervousness and agitation in our body, which can add even more stress to our lives by making us feel constantly “on edge”.
For these reasons, a lot of people are now searching for healthy coffee alternatives to get their daily energy kick, without the unpleasant jitters and afternoon crash.
The question is: are there any effective alternatives to coffee? Is there any beverage currently available on the market that can give you the energy boost you need, without the annoying side effects of coffee?
Fortunately, there are a few coffee alternatives that have been clinically proven to improve your energy levels with limited to no downside. These drinks can boost your focus and alertness, stimulate your creativity, and fuel your body with fresh energy to help you perform at your best.
That said, it’s important to be careful when choosing these alternative energy-boosting beverages, as some of them can cause side effects that are even worse than those of coffee, as we’ll see in a second…
In this article, we will present several healthy alternatives to coffee that are clinically proven to boost your energy levels without causing jitters or crashes. For each beverage, you will learn about their pros and cons, and whether or not it is a good fit for you. We also share a list of the five best coffee alternatives on the market today, according to dietitians.
Our guide has been carefully reviewed by professional nutritionists and dieticians, to ensure high-quality and accurate information.

Coffee is great, but here’s why you may want to replace it…

Many people can’t go through a single day without drinking their usual cup (or cups) of coffee. Yet, there are many downsides to drinking coffee that one should be aware of. Coffee can make our lives worse in the long-run, by causing feelings of addiction, perpetual fatigue, and even cardiac issues. We go through the risks of drinking coffee below.

Coffee causes unpleasant jitters that can add more stress to our lives

The vast majority of people who drink coffee feel “jitters” in their body within hours of consumption. They become more agitated than usual, make nervous moves, and feel constantly “on edge” (in an unpleasant, fear-inducing way).

The stress caused by coffee jitters can be detrimental to your health. According to the American Heart Association, high stress levels can lead to high-blood pressure, cholesterol, and other cardiovascular issues.

Coffee almost always comes with a crash

Almost every coffee drinker knows the feeling of being absolutely drained in the afternoon, right after the quick energy boost they experienced in the morning. These sudden crashes can take a massive toll on your productivity and overall well-being.

Coffee may cause long-term cardiac issues

Studies indicate that coffee may cause heart issues, including abnormal heartbeats and other anomalies.

In a recent study presented at the American Heart Association, researchers found that consuming coffee was associated with a 54% increase in premature ventricular contractions, a type of abnormal heartbeat occurring in the lower heart chambers.

“If we have too much [caffeine], we might start to experience anxiety, a sensation of tenseness or jitteriness, and for some, we might even experience our heart racing (palpitations),”
says Zachary Mulvihill, M.D.
integrative medicine expert at Weill Cornell Medicine and NewYork-Presbyterian in New York City.

Your body become desensitized to caffeine over time

Another major problem is that the more coffee you drink, the less responsive your body becomes. Multiple scientific studies have shown that when people consume caffeine regularly, they develop a reduced responsiveness to its stimulating effects (something called caffeine tolerance).

That means that coffee becomes less and less effective at boosting your energy with time, to a point where your body will barely feel any effect once it gets used to it. This makes coffee a non-sustainable solution to improve your energy levels over time.

What are the best alternatives to coffee?

In this section, we’re going to present some alternatives to coffee that can give you an energy boost without the unpleasant side effects.

Matcha tea

Matcha tea is a special type of green tea originating from Japan with a distinct flavor and a variety of health benefits. Many people are turning to matcha tea as a daily energy booster to replace coffee.

PROS:

  • Slow release of energy: Both coffee and matcha contain caffeine. But unlike coffee , matcha tea releases caffeine slower due to the presence of L-theanine. This can produce a gradual energy boost, reducing the risk of brutal energy crashes often associated with coffee.
  • Rich in antioxidants: Matcha contains plenty of antioxidants, specifically catechins. These antioxidants have been found to promote good health and vitality.
  • Gentle on the digestive system: Compared to coffee, matcha tea is gentler on the stomach due to a lower acidity. This can help prevent digestive issues for people who are sensitive to coffee.

CONS:

  • Still high in caffeine: While matcha does release caffeine slowly, it still contains an elevated dose of caffeine that can cause restlessness, sleeping issues, and potentially jitters. Matcha remains a highly caffeinated option that may not be suitable for people who are sensitive to caffeine.
  • Quality concerns: There are a lot of brands offering matcha tea today but very few of them are properly regulated. Quality can greatly vary from one brand to another, and low-quality matcha is likely to offer fewer health benefits.
  • Lack of convenience: Preparing high-quality matcha tea can be time-consuming as it requires at least several minutes of preparation time. This makes it a less convenient option than coffee, especially for busy people who don’t have much time. 

Yerba Mate

Yerba mate is a traditional herbal beverage from South America known for its robust, rich flavor. Heavily infused in caffeine, yerba mate can serve as an alternative energy boost to coffee.

PROS:

  • Balanced boost of energy: Yerba mate can provide an immediate stimulant effect due to caffeine it contains – although the energy kick is likely to be less strong than coffee due to a lower dose of caffeine. That said, the drink also contains theobromine, a compound known for its mild but sustained stimulating effect. Overall, the beverage can provide a milder but more prolonged energy boost than coffee.
  • Relaxing effect: Yerba Mate contains theophylline, a compound also found in green tea that has a relaxing effect on muscles. At the same time, it also acts as a stimulant for the heart and central nervous system.
  • Rich in antioxidants: The drink is a rich source of antioxidants and vitamins which altogether can improve vitality and metabolism

CONS:

  • May increase the risk of certain cancers: The consumption of yerba mate has been associated with esophageal cancer, although more research is needed on that topic.
  • Relative lack of convenience: Yerba Mate takes some time to prepare and is considered less convenient than coffee. This may be an issue for busy individuals.
  • Relatively high dose of caffeine: While the drink contains a lower dose of caffeine than coffee, it is still heavily infused with caffeine, meaning that it may cause unwanted side effects such as insomnia and jitters in some people.
  • Mild to moderate boost of energy: Many people who have tried to drink yerba mate as a replacement for coffee find that the energy boost they get is too mild compared to coffee. For people who want a significant energy boost, yerba mate may not be the best option (we present some more powerful options below).

Kombucha

Kombucha is an effervescent fermented tea that has become popular recently for offering a myriad of benefits, from gut health to energy boost. Let’s see what it’s worth as a potential alternative to coffee.

PROS:

  • Smoother boost of energy: Kombucha is known for boosting energy as it also contains caffeine – albeit in smaller amounts than coffee. The type of energy provided by Kombucha is generally considered as smoother and more sustained than that of coffee. There is also natural sugar present in kombucha, which can provide a quick energy burst shortly after consumption.
  • Rich in B vitamins: Due to its fermentation process, Kombucha is rich in B vitamins, specifically vitamin B12, which is essential for energy metabolism. These vitamins can further contribute to a boost in energy levels. The combination of caffeine with vitamins can provide a more sustained form of energy throughout the day.  
  • Digestive benefits: Rich in probiotics, Kombucha is well-known for promoting a healthy digestive system. Since gut health contributes to overall health, drinking kombucha can indirectly contribute to increasing the energy produced by our metabolism.  

CONS:

  • Potentially excessive sugar content: Several kombucha drinks contain excessive amounts of sugar that can lead to sudden energy crashes and a variety of health issues longer-term. People interested in trying kombucha should prioritize products with low amounts of sugar to avoid unwanted side effects.  
  • Inconsistent caffeine levels: The caffeine content present in kombucha can greatly vary based on its fermentation time and the variety of tea used. Some kombucha drinks are more effective than others at boosting energy due to drastic differences in caffeine content. This is a major drawback for people who are looking for a consistent boost of energy, as it requires them to try several products to see what works best for them.  
  • May cause digestive issues: Kombucha may cause adverse digestive reactions in some people, especially when consumed in large quantities.

Yaupon Tea

Originally consumed by North American indigenous tribes in ceremonial rituals, Yaupon tea is a unique variety of tea that is gradually making its way into mainstream beverages. Due to its caffeine content, Yaupon tea can also serve as a potential alternative to coffee.

PROS:

  • More balanced boost of energy: Yaupon tea contains both caffeine and theobromine. Combined together, these compounds can give a balanced boost of energy without the high and lows of coffee.
  • Digestive health benefits: Being less acidic than coffee, yaupon is gentler on the stomach which can facilitate a healthy digestion.
  • Rich in antioxidants: Due to its high concentration of antioxidants, yaupon tea helps fight oxidative stress, which can contribute to improving overall vitality.

CONS:

  • Limited research on this beverage: The amount of research backing the alleged benefits of yaupon tea is, at this point, very limited. It’s hard to know if the energy-boosting benefits of this beverage are real and grounded in science.
  • Moderate boost of energy: Many people who tried this beverage report feeling a moderate increase in energy. This drink may not be suitable for people who are looking to get a significant energy boost.
  • Strong, unusual taste that may repel newcomers: Yaupon is a very unique tea with a distinct, strong taste which may not be for everyone. While some people are not bothered by this unique taste, some newcomers may find it strange and potentially unpleasant.  

Herbal Energy Drinks

Herbal energy drinks are drinks that are specifically made to boost energy levels, while being healthier than traditional energy drinks such as Red Bull or Monster. These beverages are typically formulated with plant extracts and natural compounds capable of stimulating the body, improving alertness, and reducing fatigue.

PROS:

  • Strong boost of energy, potentially stronger than coffee: The good thing with herbal energy drinks is that they are specifically made to boost energy levels. These drinks typically contain a combination of ingredients that are carefully engineered to trigger powerful, long-lasting energy increases, using natural compounds that affect body and brain chemistry. Some of these drinks are capable of providing energy boosts that are even stronger than coffee.
  • Sustained boost of energy with less to no crashes (depending on formulation): Some herbal energy drinks can provide sustained boost of energy for the full day without causing any major energy crashes, unlike coffee and non-herbal energy drinks. This can be achieved by using specific plant-based ingredients that can supply healthy, long-term forms of energy, such as panax ginseng, ginger root, or L-theanine. Instead of giving you a temporary boost for 3-4 hours, these plant infused energy drinks can boost your energy for 10-12 hours (even beyond in some cases) due to a more progressive release of energy.  
  • Herbal energy drinks are much healthier than traditional energy drinks: Since they don’t use nasty chemicals and are mainly based on plant extracts, herbal energy drinks are significantly healthier than traditional energy drinks. These drinks can contribute to improving gut health, strengthening your metabolism, and enhancing overall vitality.  

CONS:

  • Efficacy greatly varies depending on the product: A key drawback of these drinks is that their ability to boost energy in a sustainable way greatly varies depending on the product and formulation. Some heavily marketed drinks can cause only minor increases in energy, while others can provide immediate, substantial energy boosts lasting for a long time. Due to the variability in quality, consumers should be very mindful when choosing a herbal energy drink.
  • Generally high in caffeine: Herbal energy drinks, albeit significantly healthier than traditional energy drinks, do contain large amounts of caffeine. People who are very sensitive to caffeine may want to opt for less caffeinated options. That said, some herbal energy drinks contain reasonable amounts of caffeine, sometimes lower than coffee. These drinks typically use other natural compounds on top of caffeine to boost energy.
  • Some drinks may contain artificial sweeteners: Some of these drinks contain unhealthy artificial sweeteners such as aspartame and ace-K. These chemical substances can destroy the gut flora and cause adverse health consequences in the long-term. Consumers interested in herbal energy drinks should ideally look for products that are free of aspartameor ace-K 

What you should avoid in coffee alternatives

Excess sugar.

Sugar can destroy gut health and lead to a vast range of long-term health issues. When looking for an alternative to coffee, it’s important to only look for drinks with low amounts of sugar (preferably from natural sources, like fruits)

Excessive amounts of caffeine.

Too much caffeine can cause cardiovascular issues, including irregular heartbeats. Most alternatives to coffee contain caffeine, as it remains a powerful energy stimulant. To avoid problems, stay away from drinks that contain more than 200 mg of caffeine.

Drinks that only cause mild increases in energy.

Many drinks who claim to boost your energy actually produce a very mild stimulant effect. While arguably healthier than coffee, these beverages may not serve as an ideal alternative to coffee, especially if you’re looking for a strong, noticeable energy boost throughout the day.

Drinks that useaspartame or ace-K.

Artificial sweeteners like ace-K or aspartame can damage gut health and cause long-term health issues. Stay away from drinks that contain these chemicals.

Drinks that are complex to prepare.

Convenience is also very important. If the drink is too complex or long to prepare, it may dissuade you from drinking and you may go back to your “old coffee habits”

What you should look for in coffee alternatives

Provides a strong, sustained boost of energy.

Provides a strong, sustained boost of energy. Ideally, look for drinks that can give you a sustained boost of energy so that you can feel at your best for at least 5-6 hours. The best energy-boosting beverages can have long-lasting effects, up to 12 hours in some cases. Herbal energy drinks tend to be the best option for long-term energy boost.

Doesn’t cause jitters or energy crashes.

Look for drinks that don’t cause any jitters or energy crashes. The point of replacing coffee is to avoid that annoying afternoon crash that destroys your vitality and productivity. Drinks that release caffeine slowly, or which use other energy-boosting ingredients aside from caffeine, are less likely to cause crashes. Matcha tea, yerba mate, and some herbal energy drinks do a great job at kicking your energy levels without causing afternoon crashes.

Made with healthy, natural ingredients.

It’s very important to only look for drinks made with high-quality and healthy ingredients. Stay away from high-sugar, synthetic energy drinks. Favor beverages that are only made with clean, natural ingredients. This is especially important if you’re drinking this beverage every day.

Low in sugar.

Only look for drinks that contain low to no amounts of sugar. Several kombucha products are high in sugar, so you should be careful when choosing kombucha, for instance. Most tea options presented in this article are very low on sugar. Herbal energy drinks typically contain a few grams of sugar, but the amount contained is usually too small to make any difference.

Easy and convenient to consume.

Ideally, the drink should be easy to prepare and consume. That way, it makes it easier to stick to this habit and remove coffee from your routine.

Contain a moderate amount of caffeine.

Look for drinks that contain reasonable amounts of caffeine. Anything above 200 mg per drink is excessive and may cause unwanted side effects. According to nutritionists, the sweet spot for stimulation is around 70 to 95 mg - a dose strong enough to kickstart your energy levels, without causing jitters or crashes.

Free of unhealthy artificial sweeteners.

Only choose drinks that are completely free of bad artificial sweeteners such as ace-K or aspartame. This mostly applies to herbal energy drinks as tea beverages rarely contain these sweeteners.

The Top 5 Best Coffee Alternatives On The Market Today, According To Nutritionists

To help you choose an energy drink that will give you a strong boost of energy without the crash, we’ve compiled a list of the top 5 best coffee alternatives on the market. This list was carefully curated in partnership with certified nutritionists, and takes several factors into consideration, including: ingredients quality, health impact, taste, value for money, and verified customer reviews.

#1 Alpine Bliss Cognitive Energy Booster

Final Grade

9.5 /10

Energy Boost

9.5/10

Taste

9.7/10

Value for Money

9.0/10

Ingredient Quality

9.5/10

Scientific Evidence

9.2/10

THE BOTTOM LINE

Alpine Bliss is a premium, fast-growing Swiss brand of flavored sparkling water offering functional health benefits, using clinically studied ingredients. The Alpine Bliss Peak Performance Energy Booster is a fruity herbal energy drink that combines pure alpine water sourced from the European Alps with natural energy-boosting ingredients based on plants.
One of the key benefits of this herbal energy drink is its ability to provide a strong, sustained boost of energy for several hours, without causing unpleasant energy crashes often associated with coffee.
This is achieved through a unique blend of high-quality plant-based ingredients, including 70 mg of caffeine from natural source, L-tyrosine, panax ginseng, saffron and high-purity ginger root extract. Some users report feeling energized even one day after consuming the drink, which may be due to the long-term energy-boosting effects of saffron and ginger root. No case of insomnia or sleep issues were reported.
Consumers also report experiencing a powerful and clean boost of energy, comparable to that of high-dose coffees or regular energy drinks, without jitters or afternoon crashes.
Aside from enhancing mental and physical energy, this formula is also known for creating a distinct feeling of well-being thanks to a proprietary blend of plant-based ingredients called DopaBliss. This natural blend is specifically designed to boost cognitive levels – the “happy hormone” responsible for making us feel good and happy.
From a nutrition standpoint, the drink is also scoring pretty well. The formula contains zero added sugar, just 25 calories per can, and only 5 grams of natural sugar from wild berries. It doesn’t contain any harmful artificial sweeteners like aspartame or ace-K. The drink is also a rich source of vitamin B6 and B12 – two vitamins that promote a healthy metabolism.
Beyond its functional health benefits, the Alpine Bliss formula also performs well on taste, according to consumers. Users praise its fruity wild berries flavor and refreshing fine bubbles. It strikes a delicate balance of sweetness and freshness, and delivers an enjoyable drinking experience.
Taking all of this into consideration puts Alpine Bliss Cognitive Energy booster in our #1 spot.

#2 Sencha Naturals Everyday Matcha

Final Grade

8.8 /10

Energy Boost

8.5/10

Taste

9.0/10

Value for Money

9.0/10

Ingredient Quality

8.5/10

Scientific Evidence

9.0/10

THE BOTTOM LINE

Sencha Naturals Everyday Matcha is a top-rated matcha powder that has a strong reputation among matcha enthusiasts.
It is sourced from specially grown and processed leaves of the camellia sinensis plant. This finely powdered green tea is high in antioxidants and offers other powerful health-promoting benefits, including increased memory and cognition, reduced stress and inflammation, and antiviral compounds that strengthen the body’s immune system.
One of the benefits of drinking Sencha Naturals Everyday Matcha is that it provides a natural energy boost without causing jitters or energy crashes, unlike coffee. This is because matcha contains an amino acid called L-theanine, which promotes relaxation and calmness while also improving focus and concentration.
In addition to its energy-boosting properties, Sencha Naturals Everyday Matcha can be enjoyed hot or cold, mixed into smoothies, baked into desserts, or used as a twist on lemonade. It is also vegan, gluten-free, and non-GMO.
The combination of caffeine and L-theanine in matcha provides a sustained energy boost without the negative side effects often associated with caffeine consumption -making it a solid alternative to coffee.
However, there are also some drawbacks to consider when it comes to Sencha Naturals Everyday Matcha. One con is that the energy boost it provides is mild at best. While matcha does contain caffeine, it’s not as strong as coffee and may not provide the same level of energy boost. Additionally, preparing matcha can be less convenient than other beverages, as it requires whisking the powder into hot water to create a frothy drink.

#3 Celsius Stevia

Final Grade

8.5 /10

Energy Boost

8.2/10

Taste

8.5/10

Value for Money

8.8/10

Ingredient Quality

8.6/10

Scientific Evidence

8.4/10

THE BOTTOM LINE

Celsius Stevia is another herbal energy drink that aims to provide a powerful boost of energy while offering several nutritional benefits.
One of the key features of Celsius is its low-calorie content. This makes it an attractive option for those watching their calorie intake while still seeking an energy boost.
The energy-enhancing effects of Celsius can be attributed to its high dose of caffeine and guarana seed. These ingredients provide a potent and immediate surge of energy. Another positive aspect of Celsius is its inclusion of green tea extracts, which are rich in antioxidants. Antioxidants are known for their health benefits, supporting overall well-being.
One of the advantages of Celsius is its wide range of tastes and flavors. This allows consumers to choose the option that best suits their preferences and keeps things interesting.
However, there are a couple of considerations to keep in mind. The caffeine dose in Celsius Stevia is relatively high at 200 mg. For individuals sensitive to caffeine or looking to limit their intake, this may be a drawback. Such a high dose of caffeine may cause unpleasant crashes in some people, which would defeat the purpose of drinking coffee alternatives.
Additionally, while this drink uses Stevia as a sweetener (which is safe), it also contains the artificial sweetener erythritol. While more research is needed, there are some concerns that erythritol may have negative effects on cardiovascular health. Although Celsius is a very good healthier alternative to coffee, it’s important to be aware of this potential downside and consider your individual health needs.

#4 Guayaki Yerba Mate

Final Grade

8.2 /10

Energy Boost

8.5/10

Taste

7.8/10

Value for Money

8.2/10

Ingredient Quality

8.3/10

Scientific Evidence

8.1/10

THE BOTTOM LINE

Guayaki Organic Yerba Mate provides a clean energy boost derived from naturally caffeinated yerba mate leaves. The brand has a good reputation and receives strong consumer reviews, based on Amazon reviews.
With a strong dose of 80 mg of caffeine, Guayaki Organic Yerba Mate offers a suitable level of stimulation for an energizing effect, and it’s not excessively high, mitigating the risk of energy crash. It can help you stay alert and focused when needed.
For those conscious of their calorie intake, Guayaki Organic Yerba Mate is low in calories, making it a good choice for individuals seeking an energy boost without excessive caloric content. It is also free from artificial sweeteners.
Although Guayaki Organic Yerba Mate contains 5 mg of sodium, which may not be ideal for some individuals, it is generally considered acceptable for most consumers.
However, it’s important to note that some studies suggest that yerba mate leaves may contain polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which are known carcinogens. Further research is needed to fully understand the potential risks associated with PAHs in yerba mate consumption. Overall, the benefits appear to overpower the drawbacks.

#5 GT’s Enlightened Organic Raw Kombucha

Final Grade

7.7 /10

Energy Boost

7.9/10

Taste

7.7/10

Value for Money

7.5/10

Ingredient Quality

7.8/10

Scientific Evidence

7.6/10

THE BOTTOM LINE

GT’s Enlightened Organic Raw Kombucha is a popular kombucha product. It’s handcrafted in small batches, offering billions of living probiotics to help you live a healthier life.
One of the key benefits of GT’s Enlightened Organic Raw Kombucha is that it provides a natural energy boost without causing jitters or energy crashes, unlike coffee. This is mostly due to the presence of L-Theanine, promoting clean, sustained energy. The combination of caffeine and L-theanine in kombucha provides a sustained energy boost without the negative side effects often associated with caffeine consumption.
On the other side, there are a few downsides to think about with GT’s Enlightened Organic Raw Kombucha. For starters, while it does give you a bit of an energy kick, it’s not as strong as what you’d get from coffee. This is because even though kombucha has caffeine in it, it doesn’t have as much as coffee does.
Another thing is that kombucha isn’t as easy to prepare and drink as some other drinks. Since the drink requires refrigeration, you have to keep it in the fridge, and once you’ve opened it, you need to drink it fairly quickly.
In addition to its energy-boosting properties, GT’s Enlightened Organic Raw Kombucha can be enjoyed cold and is vegan, gluten-free, and non-GMO.
Scroll to Top